We’ve detected that you are using an outdated browser.

Please use a new browser like Chrome, Firefox, Safari or Microsoft Edge to improve your experience.

We’ve detected that you are using an outdated browser.


Does Farmland Protection Pay? The Cost of Community Services in Three Massachusetts Towns

One common claim made to Massachusetts towns is that residential development increases the local tax base, thereby lowering property taxes. Others are that resource conservation is too expensive at the local level, and that farmland does not make a significant contribution to the tax base, so it is best converted to its “highest and best use,” which is generally assumed to be development.

The American Farmland Trust (AFT) is a private, national conservation organization with a regional office in Northampton, Massachusetts. AFT was concerned that local officials lacked data to support or dismiss these claims. Working with three Pioneer Valley towns on cost of community services (COCS) studies, AFT found that although residential development increases the local tax base, it does not pay for itself. These towns paid more on residential services than they received from residential revenues. On the other hand, while privately owned farm and open lands do not raise nearly as much gross income as developed land uses, their need for services is so modest, their net effect on the tax base is a surplus. In this COCS study of three Massachusetts towns, AFT found the average ratio of dollars generated by residential development to services required was $1 to $1.12 — for every dollar raised by residential revenues, the towns spent an extra 12 cents in direct services. These included education and social programs, public health and safety, highway maintenance and public works, and even local government. On the other hand, the average ratio for farm, forest and open land was $1 to 33 cents — for every dollar raised after the towns provided services, 67 cents remained.

Publication Name
AFT Publication
Downloadable Documents
Julia Freedgood
Northampton, MA: American Farmland Trust
Page Numbers
iii, 38
Publication Date
June 01, 1992
Publication Type
Reports and Guides
Cost of Community Services

Visit American Farmland Trust

Get engaged and receive the information you need right in your inbox.